Dennehy Juror Gives Behind-The-Scenes Glimpse - KATV - Breaking News, Weather and Razorback Sports

Dennehy Juror Gives Behind-The-Scenes Glimpse

Posted: Updated:

The images are still shocking. A man who had just fired a gun on the courthouse square, apparently hoping for suicide by cop.

"It was definitely just stressful," said Kayla McCall. She spent two weeks sitting on the jury that would decide Andrew Dennehy's fate. The crux of his defense? Not guilty by reason of insanity.

"I mean I would sit there and listen, I'd be like, 'Ok, where's the insane part?" she said.

Four jurors, she says, gave serious thought to the insanity plea, but eventually everyone came to the conclusion that Dennehy knew what he was doing. A key piece of evidence for her? Dennehy's demeanor in the courtyard.

"In the video he walked on the plaza calmly," she said.

They deliberated for roughly seven hours, deciding on a term of 20 years for the main charge of shooting with intent to kill. Law enforcement was not pleased.

"That's the verdict from the jury and that's what we have to respect, but it just seems like the guy got off pretty easy," said Major Shannon Clark with the Tulsa County Sheriffs Office.

"Nobody's going to be happy either way with what we decided to do, but then on the second hand, he didn't kill the cop," said McCall.

Had that happened she says, they would have given a life sentence. As it is...

"He will be behind bars for 23 years by the time he even considers to even get out. So, to me I think that's a long enough sentence of 23 years," she said.

  • Top Videos

Most Popular

Stories
Videos
loading...
  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Mount Vernon community remembers hit-and-run victim’s life

    Mount Vernon community remembers hit-and-run victim’s life

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 5:12 PM EDT2014-08-27 21:12:49 GMT
    Heather Danielle Baker's infectious smile was on the minds of all who attended her memorial in Mount Vernon on Aug. 25. Family and friends filled the Mount Vernon-Enola High School gym, most wearing purple in celebration of Baker's life.More >>
    Heather Danielle Baker's infectious smile was on the minds of all who attended her memorial in Mount Vernon on Aug. 25. Family and friends filled the Mount Vernon-Enola High School gym, most wearing purple in celebration of Baker's life.More >>
  • Jermain Taylor pleads not guilty, given $25K bond

    Jermain Taylor pleads not guilty, given $25K bond

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 5:11 PM EDT2014-08-27 21:11:53 GMT
    Professional Boxer Jermain Taylor has pleaded not guilty on charges for first degree battery and aggravated assault. Wednesday morning, he was given a $25,000 bond by Pulaski County District Court Judge Wayne Gruber.More >>
    Professional Boxer Jermain Taylor has pleaded not guilty on charges for first degree battery and aggravated assault. Wednesday morning, he was given a $25,000 bond by Pulaski County District Court Judge Wayne Gruber.More >>
  • Woman cleared of wrongdoing, officer fired after withholding evidence

    Woman cleared of wrongdoing, officer fired after withholding evidence

    Woman cleared of wrongdoing, officer fired after withholding evidence

    Tuesday, August 26 2014 10:22 PM EDT2014-08-27 02:22:22 GMT
    Officer Mark WinchesterOfficer Mark Winchester
    FAULKNER COUNTY (KATV)--A Mayflower Police officer is fired, after a prosecutor said he withheld evidence regarding an investigation. Officer Mark Winchester was terminated this morning. More >>
    FAULKNER COUNTY (KATV)--A Mayflower Police officer is fired, after a prosecutor said he withheld evidence regarding an investigation. Officer Mark Winchester was terminated this morning. More >>