Oklahoma Girl's Adoption Dispute in Supreme Court Today - KATV - Breaking News, Weather and Razorback Sports

Oklahoma Girl's Adoption Dispute in Supreme Court Today

Posted: Updated:
Veronica with her birth father Dusten Brown in this photo provided by the Cherokee Nation. Veronica with her birth father Dusten Brown in this photo provided by the Cherokee Nation.

A custody battle involving an Oklahoma child will head to the Supreme Court today as justices take another look at the Indian Child Welfare Act.

The legal fight centers around a little girl named Veronica. She was adopted by Matt and Melanie Capobianco of South Carolina shortly after she was born.

But her birth father, Dusten Brown, lives in Oklahoma and is a member of the Cherokee Nation. Brown regained custody in 2011 under the Indian Child Welfare Act -- a law meant to protect Native American tribe culture by keeping American Indian children with their American Indian parents.

Former South Carolina Attorney General Charlie Condon says the strict legal question before the justices will be whether or not the biological father in this case is a "parent" in the meaning of the Indian Child Welfare Act.

There are reports that the biological father, Dusten Brown, did not provide emotional or financial support to Veronica's mother during the pregnancy.

The Justices will want to make clear what a parent means under the act and whether federal law should take precedent over state law.

"If you look at South Carolina state law they have some winning arguments that the baby should stay here," Condon said. "It's a very interesting mix of factual, legal questions and interplay between the federal and state government that involves this really emotional subject of where the child should stay."

The Indian Child Welfare Act has only been taken up by the Supreme Court twice since it was enacted in 1978.

"The fact that the Supreme Court took jurisdiction in this case is a positive development because otherwise they would have been out of luck and the baby would have remained with the father," Former South Carolina Attorney General Charlie Condon says. "So it's very positive that the Supreme Court is hearing this."

"It's a challenging case though because that statute gives very strong presence for that child remaining with the father so I do believe that they do have a challenge ahead of them to win this case."

A ruling on the case by the Supreme Court is expected to come down in June.

- Stefanie Bainum, for KTUL.com

Most Popular

Stories
Videos
loading...
  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Lockdown lifted at Little Rock Air Force Base

    Lockdown lifted at Little Rock Air Force Base

    Wednesday, July 23 2014 5:48 PM EDT2014-07-23 21:48:11 GMT
    The lockdown at Little Rock Air Force Base has been lifted.More >>
    The lockdown at Little Rock Air Force Base has been lifted.More >>
  • 20 year old Stuttgart man shot while walking his dog dies

    20 year old Stuttgart man shot while walking his dog dies

    Wednesday, July 23 2014 11:50 PM EDT2014-07-24 03:50:30 GMT
    UPDATE: 20 year old Daniel Ruffin passed away Wednesday night. STUTTGART (KATV) - Community members held a prayer vigil for Daniel Ruffin after he was shot in the chest on Tuesday night. Ruffin was walking his dog in front of his home on South Maple street just after 5 pm when he was shot. Neighbors At Wednesday's vigil Ruffin's family was warmly consoled and encouraged by neighbors.More >>
    UPDATE: 20 year old Daniel Ruffin passed away Wednesday night. STUTTGART (KATV) - Community members held a prayer vigil for Daniel Ruffin after he was shot in the chest on Tuesday night. Ruffin was walking his dog in front of his home on South Maple street just after 5 pm when he was shot. Neighbors At Wednesday's vigil Ruffin's family was warmly consoled and encouraged by neighbors. More >>
  • FOLLOW-UP: Coroner says "pure speculation" if son would have been saved

    FOLLOW-UP: Coroner says "pure speculation" if son would have been saved

    Wednesday, July 23 2014 6:51 PM EDT2014-07-23 22:51:41 GMT
    CONWAY (KATV) – The Faulkner County Coroner said it was a lethal combination of a multitude of drugs that ultimately killed 20 year-old Joshua Ashley-Pauley – the son of the man holding a sign public shaming his son’s friends who he believes did nothing to help save his son. More >>
    CONWAY (KATV) – The Faulkner County Coroner said it was a lethal combination of a multitude of drugs that ultimately killed 20 year-old Joshua Ashley-Pauley – the son of the man holding a sign public shaming his son’s friends who he believes did nothing to help save his son. More >>